Longest standing podcast subscription! What I appreciate most about these ladies after all this time is that they don’t box themselves into the tone of “Redhanded”, they are just real and raw. I love going back to listen to a block of old episodes and being like oh this is when Hannah was in her correction fairy era. Or this is when Suruthi’s sass level got turned to 1000%. You don’t always have to agree with the everything the hosts of your favorite podcasts says, but you do have to appreciate the content they create that makes you care enough to be upset about the rare occurrence that you don’t agree with them. Sooo appreciative of all of your content throughout the years! I used to mark all of the short handed as played without listening and now I get alerts for them because they are some of my favorites! PS - Hannah, I need you to play Ursula as you mentioned in an episode. Maybe both Ariel and Ursula? Pull a Suruthi and cast yourself as the main character, but one up her by playing the main the largest supporting role. Xoxo, thanks sistas, hope you make it to 1,000.

I enjoyed the show but the constant jabs at Trump are ridiculous to the point I just had to stop listening.

You should really keep politics out of your stories.

I love all the research and context given. Yall havw great chemistry and even when k dont agree I find your opinions and reasons for them interesting and they cause me to re-examine my own and take into account other perspectives. I love the stories yall choose and how you tell them! Above and beyond 💗

Love it! Long time listener. The only thing is the sound quality. It that it sounds like y’all whisper sometimes. Then when I turn it up, it’s too loud. The mics might be too sensitive? There’s too much discrepancy between the louder moments and softer moments vocally speaking. I could be the only one feeling this way- or maybe it’s all my previous years working as a bartendress in loud bars. Just a heads up. Love the show!

I heard you first when you were on Morbid! I found your channel and have listened every day since then!

Their cadence is so slow it’s almost painful.

Both are fantastic

Very entertaining to watch, unfortunately true crime is consumed as fictional stories instead of seeing them for the horrific crimes they are. Naturally this leaves some of the serious cases handled with little tact or the respect they deserve.

Been listening for years, and if a podcast can hook this East Coast lefty millennial AND my conservative midwestern father, they’re doing something right. Thanks for making our phone calls less awkward. The hosts are funny and well-versed on the topics they discuss without presenting themselves as experts. Most of the negative reviews seem to be from people who disagree with their conclusions about a specific case. While the hosts won’t hesitate to critique a point of view (often hilariously, which probably stings if it’s yours), they try to cover topics from all sides while being honest about their own views. Huge fan and excited to see what new projects are on the horizon!

Omg! I just now found this podcast after reading their book. Favorite podcast ever.

When I first discovered red handed I was like this is kinda fire, and now I’m like “THIS IS LITERALLY THE BEST PODCAST.” I always recommend this to people, cuz it’s really entertaining. Y’all make true crime not boring. And I wish I could give this 10 out of 5 stars but whatever.

😘

What have I been wasting my time listening to? Everything else in comparison now seems beige and bleh…how is this not #1?

Best true crime podcasts

The constant side bars are exhausting to listen to. This podcast run time could be fit in half if they would fit out the nonstop pointless side bars. Complete lack of compassion/respect for victims.

I absolutely love yalls show!! I have noticed every few months I’m not following the pod anymore though and I have to refollow you?? Super weird, idk how to let Apple know that though.

I have been listening for 2 years and after the Menendez case I bid farewell and looks like I’m not alone. Clearly had a bias view prior and would have been better not to report this case. The limited research and lack of new information presented makes me think they just watched Ryan Murphy’s show. The last straw was victim shaming and claiming no evidence when there has been evidence you could google. And finally, blaming the female jurors that their “maternal instinct” got the best of them to believe the victims. Disgusting. Goodbye.

I feel that Hannah and Suruthi do an excellent job delivering true crime in a considerate and intelligent way that is sensitive to those affected by these crimes and rightfully brutal to the perpetrators. I appreciate the different perspectives and the variety of stories throughout the world they both share that deserve to be told to honor the people that have been lost, the survivors, and their loved ones. Thank you both for being such dedicated, honest, and caring storytellers.

Did you do any real research in to the Menendez case or did you only watch Ryan Murphys show.

My only “complaint” is that Hannah’s voice is often louder than Suruthi so it’s hard to find a volume that you can hear one of them without the other being unpleasantly loud. They are two very smart and funny brits! I love how accepting and open minded. The stories are interesting. Anyone upset about their political opinion should realize that they aren’t Americans. The whole world doesn't need to be an American Cosplaytriot😅

I thought I had found a great true crime podcast so have been going through the archive — I’m appalled at the lack of care and compassion that these hosts have for victims (specifically citing the Colleen Stan podcast). I am genuinely shocked at the way they presented this case and really cannot continue listening to them after hearing this. The more I learn about the injustices this podcast has committed against victims, the more I am nauseated. There is such blatant xenophobia and classism riddled throughout their alleged analyses — which also significantly lack actual research — that it’s impossible to support any longer.

I look forward to hearing from these ladies every day. I think I found my favorite podcast! Love you girls keep up the great work!

More than the crime itself, listening to you two drop f bombs in your wonderful English accents is what keeps me coming back. Love your banter.

I LOVE the amazing work these ladies have done, do, and will do. Unfortunately, I found out Wondery (their parent company) is owned by Amazon and I cannot continue in good conscience as a listener.

If you are looking for a true crime podcast this is it. Don’t look anywhere else. This is the best true crime podcast PERIOD!!

There’s no podcast better than Redhanded. I learn something new about history, politics, science . But the best part is that the presenters don’t go on and on about themselves.

I appreciate how the hosts structure stories in most cases and they have particularly nice voices but they have some pretty bad, uninformed takes at some points. Maybe a handful times an episode they’ll either have a random aside or hot take on the case that make no sense and are sometimes even rude

I’m really grateful for the high quality content and especially the vulgar language. Since I’m not you know a child or so uptight I clutch pearls into dust I really prefer my podcasts talk to me like a friend. If I wanna be lied to and talked to like a child I’ll hit up Fox News. Thank god these women are badasses and keep us entertained.

Y’all are amazing. Who ever thought listening to True Crime could be soothing. Y’all’s voices are so soothing y’all are funny love the banter why did it take me so long to find y’all keep doing this!!! Gotta give a shout out to the Morbid Girls for having you on I would have never known this is where I am supposed to be I really wish I could give you all 10 stars love yall soooo much

The content is very interesting, however the vulgar language is not necessary, unfollowing today

Why can’t these ladies(I use loosely) own up to being wrong! They should admit when they are wrong and more on. I would come back to listening but can’t get past there bad character

One of the more attractive features of RedHanded has been the intelligent, creative and interesting content. Unfortunately there seem to be more and more painfully one-sided interruptions as of late that come across as painfully arrogant and are truly off-putting. You’re better and smarter than that!

I like the show, it’s honestly good. There’s too much of the f-word unfortunately, and they don’t seem to like the USA very much. Suruthi can reeeeeally monologue. I hit fast-forward literally 6 times and she was still going. They can be funny though, so hopefully it doesn’t wear on me.

I’ve never left a review on a podcast before, but I feel compelled to write this… while I love your topics and find your shows very well written and your voices very pleasing to listen to, your habit of whispering all the important information you want to emphasize while turning up the volume on the commercials, makes it impossible for me to enjoy your show unless I keep one hand on my phone to adjust the sound continually. I can’t believe I’m alone in having this reaction to your delivery, and as I don’t have time to do this, you’ve just lost me as a listener. Just sign me sad and unhappy and frustrated.

The best true crime podcast around. The hosts bring the perfect amount of levity.

I find it hard to get a steady volume to hear these gals. They seem to try and build tension for a story, but then finish sentences so quietly I cannot hear what they’re saying. Overall I usually like their stories, but it drives me crazy to constantly turn the volume up and down.

What a lazy podcast. They did bare minimum research on the Karen Read Case & form a ridiculous opinion on it. Karen Read did not kill John. Watch the trial ya know research. Here are some facts for you 1. The FBI hired car reconstruction specialists that conclude John was 100% not hit by a car and are investigating DA in canton 2. The house owners a Boston cop but never came outside after John was found on the lawn and police lights blaring outside & Karen screaming even with their dog who barks incessantly usually. Police never went into the house. 3. Jen McCabe 1000% google searched "hos long to die in the cold" at 2:27am before John's body was found and deleted it & was she also caught lieing dozens of time on the stand. See video 4. Snow plow driver saw no body on the lawn the two times he came by in middle of night only a Ford edge the Albert's drive. 5. Higgins & Albert both destroyed their phones the day before they were supposed to be turned in to evidence 6. They used solo cups and grocery bags to collect evidence contaminating everything. 7. John had blunt force trauma back if head and dog bites on his arms but no bruising below the neck impossible for a car hitting a pedestrian. 8 the dog Chloe had a history of biting people and was rehomed before they could investigate. 9. Police never collected ring footage from anyone with cameras on Fairview. 10. Lead investigator wrote disgusting texts about Karen looking for nudes in Karen's phone calling her vile names like c@nt and said she should kill herself. 11. Lead investigator is on non paid leave for his unethical behavior and is friends with the people framing Karen & group texted private details to people about case. 12. 18 supposed butt dial calls between the group framing Karen they also deleted. 13. They inverted the video in the sally port showing them messing with the tailight. 14. The judge is so biased it should be illegal doesnt let you give reasons for objections favors prosecutor 15. Blood & vomit on John's boxers but not on pants or shirt. 16. No blood on car at all. 17. The initial statements by cops says John was in a fight. 18. 360 app proves witness's lieing about locations in timeline. 19. Karen connects to WiFi at John's house at the time prosecutors claim she was at 34 Fairview hitting John. 20. Sooo much corruption etc etc etc etc.

Wow. When my sister shared this with me, I didn’t realize id want you to be in my ears at any chance I got. Thank you for hundreds of amazing episodes!! Your scripts are amazing.

Out of the Otto Warmbier episode, I learned that these two British women don’t like Americans flying American flags, white supremacy goes hand in hand with flag flying, they don’t like how Donald Trump handled the case, etc. This isn’t why I tuned into this podcast. I just wanted to learn more about this heartbreaking story without all of the preachy lecturing. Is this how Wondery feels about the USA and its people?

I just discovered these ladies and I’m obsessed! Witty with F bombs, my love language.

Love it !!!!

The episodes are entertaining enough, but research and journalistic integrity are lacking.

Long-time listener, first-time reviewer—love the podcast! That said, I’ve noticed the audio levels are a bit uneven. The episode volume, especially Suruthi’s voice, is often so low that I have trouble hearing clearly, while the commercials come on much louder in comparison. It’d be great if this could be balanced out for a smoother listening experience. Keep up the great work!

I have been listening to the podcast and enjoying it. However, the Holy Grail episode had 2 obvious mistakes. 1. Transmutation is not a catholic belief. Podcast mentions it is a Christian belief but not a Catholic one. It is one of the most important premises of Catholicism so not sure how was this not known if research was adequately done. 2. Joseph of Arimatea is not the husband of the Virgin Mary who raised Jesus.He donated the tomb where Jesus was put to rest and is believed to have been related to Mary but not St Joseph. Minor things that bother me as to the level of effort put into putting together an episode.

My rating and review, like all the ratings and reviews, are just my personal opinion. Personally, I really dislike podcasts where the hosts just start ripping and joking, and talking to each other as friends and inside jokes throughout the podcast story. I’m listening to them to hear the story, not to hear them crack jokes with each other about their past lives or friendships or whatever. And there’s a ton of that in this podcast, so I don’t like this podcast that’s the reason. Not saying the content isn’t good, just that I don’t like the presentation.

Really enjoy the show. Can the producers please adjust the volume levels before publishing? Commercials are so loud compared to the show itself. Even during the show levels aren’t consistent.

It feels like the hosts, or host (Hannah) spends a lot of time slagging off other countries and cultures. So far I’ve heard her express negativity for, Sweden, Wales, USA and the Neatherlands and I’ve only listened to 3 episodes 😂 We get it you’re super proud to be English. But I’m sure she’d say I’m just getting my ‘panties in a bunch’.

Part 1 of Jim Jones could have been reduced to ten minutes and out into the other episode. Also, you guys definitely should have watched the Jon Benet Netflix documentary before you produced your JB show because in light of that doc, the ep sounds really misinformed and overlooks a lot of new info that was clarified through the doc.

To those leaving snarky or rude comments: let’s take a moment to appreciate what this podcast truly is. RedHanded is Hannah and Suruthi’s show—a platform for them to share their thoughts, opinions, and storytelling style. We tune in because we value their work, not to demand they censor themselves, cater to every individual experience, or produce episodes that address every possible angle in painstaking detail. The way they research, record, and edit is a reflection of their creative process—it’s their art. Constructive criticism is fine, but there’s a clear line between offering thoughtful feedback and being unnecessarily harsh. Ask yourself: has tearing someone down ever been productive? Hannah and Suruthi are exceptionally talented—intelligent, witty, articulate, and their chemistry is what makes the show so compelling. Let’s show them the respect they deserve for the immense effort they pour into creating something remarkable for their audience. From one listener to another, with love, Ash in New Mexico